With the upscale Greek restaurant Kellari Taverna, Stavros Aktipis and his partners have created a warm, rollicking, woody milieu with high-beamed ceilings, an open kitchen, hardwood floors, wine racks, mirrors, soft lighting, and beautiful bouquets. Aktipis -- who owned Avra, an elegant, excellent East Side Hellenic hangout -- has patterned Kellari similarly.
Kellari, which means “wine cellar,” is true to its Greek roots. There’s a display of whole fish on ice that is the restaurant’s featured attraction, along with an extensive wine list that offers more Greek selections (about 100) than any place in the city -- or even the country. Fish dominates the menu; lamb and vegetables run second and third. They’re all enhanced with herbs, olive oil, and lemon. The very fresh fish is often brushed with olive oil, grilled and garnished with lemon, or cooked in the oven with herbs and eggplant. Artichokes, yogurt, and goat and feta cheeses can be found throughout the menu.
In many ways, though, Kellari Taverna is a wine-centered restaurant. Bottles are kept cool in large copper bowls; a balcony wine-rack display holds bottles used for the many wine-by-the-glass possibilities; and its extensive list is divided between international and Greek options. Although many of the French, Spanish, and other regional wines here are admirable, most are widely available elsewhere. The Greek ones aren’t, however, and they go extremely well with the food. (Modern Greek wines are world-class, not the primitive stuff of yesteryear.)
Appetizers include warm grilled octopus in a vibrant tangle of onions, peppers, capers, olive oil, red-wine vinegar, and baked goat cheese studded with spiced apricots. Spanakopita, or spinach-stuffed phyllo triangles, was standard while grilled calamari was superior: tender and alive with herbs, lemon juice, and olive oil.
All four entrées scored: The fork-tender lamb shank; the stew-like oven-roasted Chilean sea bass with potatoes and Vidalia onions; the flaky grilled salmon; and especially the pristine, whole imported Tsipoura. The last, an ivory fillet, yielded a subtle flavor.
Subtle, too, was masticha, a difficult-to-describe anise-like mousse dessert paired with fruit stewed in honey syrup and Muscat wine from the island of Samos. Thick, hearty sheep’s-milk yogurt was strewn with wild cherries, and galaktoboureko, a large wedge of rich custard with red orange sauce, satisfied -- as did sokolata, chocolate soufflé in a chocolate cup with an appropriate halva mousse offset.
19 W. 44th St. btw. Fifth & Sixth Aves., 212-221-0144; www.kellari.us
Richard Jay
Scholem was a restaurant critic for the New York Times' Long Island
section for 14 years. His A La Carte column appeared from 1990 to 2004.
For more "Taste of the Town" reviews, click here.
Dining Review: Kellari Taverna
New York City Activities
More Articles
Dine Like a New Yorker: Why Redeye Grill & Brooklyn Diner USA are Two of the Best Restaurants in Midtown NYC
Experience the best of NYC dining at Redeye Grill & Brooklyn Diner USA on 57th St. Enjoy top-notch cuisine & ambience near at these restaurants near Carnegie Hall in Midtown Manhattan.
Where to Eat When Visiting Manhattan’s Museum Mile
Explore a diverse range of dining experiences near Manhattan's Museum Mile, from international cuisines like Austrian and Greek to classic Italian and French options.
Best Late Night Desserts in NYC
From iconic cannolis at Caffe Palermo in Little Italy to nostalgic desserts at Empire Diner, there are great places all around NYC when that late-night sweet tooth starts to tingle. Read on for great shakes, cakes, cookies, and more in the wee hours.
Utsav Introduces New Bengali Menu
Utsav, a woman-owned restaurant in the Theater District, has been serving a dynamic combination of Chinese and Indian cuisine now for more than 23 years. They've recently introduced a Bengali menu.
Mozart's Requiem at David Geffen Hall, Lincoln Center on 5/26/24
Jonathan Griffith, Artistic Director and Principal Conductor of Distinguished Concerts International
Watson Adventures’ Escape From Grand Central Scavenger Hunt at Grand Central Station on 2/17/48
Congratulations: You’ve been poisoned! That’s the bad news at the start of this scavenger hunt for a
No, But I’m Definitely In A Better Place Than I’ve Been In A Long Time at The Brick on 5/23/24
A raging narcissist attempts to put up a one-man show about his dog as the world is ending. Micha
When Women Ran Fifth Avenue: Glamour and Power at the Dawn of American Fashion at Online on 5/21/24
Award-winning author of "The Plaza," Julie Satow looks south on Fifth Avenue and back through the 20