Dining Review: Sofrito
Every dish at Sofrito (named for an aromatic mix of Puerto Rican herbs and spices) is formidable and fashionable. Diners begin with a dish of warm fried bread. A starter of four melt-in-the-mouth, sauced barbecue pork ribs come leaning on a mammoth mound of rich, creamy potato salad. A plateful of tiny fried shrimp, with two tangy dipping sauces , are tender, crisp, and crunchy, and a broad shouldered white bean and vegetable soup, dense with plantains, pork chunks, potatoes, veggies, and more arrives in an iron pot with enough for four hearty eaters. Only a rather tired chopped salad missed the mark.
A hefty, moderately spicy Puerto Rican lobster gumbo, filled with generous pieces of shellfish, also came in a large, heavy pot. It was messy to eat but worth the effort. Shrimp in a delicious, garlic-infused white wine sauce would do the fanciest of French restaurants proud.
Entrees were plated with worthwhile accompaniments like that great potato salad, savory sauteed spinach replete with garlic, and slightly dry green pigeon pea rice. Every entree arrives with a side dish and a choice of diverse sauces. A bountiful stack of pork chops was tasty and tender. Be sure to order them medium rare to retain most of their moisture. A delicate, fresh, pan-roasted filet of grouper was as good as that dish gets. So was the smooth, velvety cheese flan dessert. The commendable, traditional tres leches was, as the menu promised, a "moist sponge cake bathed in three types of milk." The numero uno sweet was the sinfully intense ramekin of chocolate bread pudding, with its caramel sauce and vanilla ice cream plate mates.
Prices at this increasingly popular Puerto Rican, rollicking spot are considerably lower than those at typical upscale Manhattan eating places. The stomach-filling lobster gumbo cost $17; the white bean and vegetable soup goes for $5, as do all side dishes and desserts. The shrimp, pork chop, and grouper main courses all were in the $14 to $16 range. Every one of them is a remarkable bargain in a city studded with restaurants that often charge stratospheric prices.
From Friday to Monday, there is also a live Latin band to further spice up Sofrito's vibrant atmosphere.
400 E. 57th St. at First Ave., 212-754-5999; www.sofritony.com
Richard Jay Scholem was a restaurant critic for the New York Times' Long Island section for 14 years. His A La Carte column appeared from 1990 to 2004. For more "Taste of the Town" reviews, click here.
New York City Activities
More Articles
Dine Like a New Yorker: Why Redeye Grill & Brooklyn Diner USA are Two of the Best Restaurants in Midtown NYC
Experience the best of NYC dining at Redeye Grill & Brooklyn Diner USA on 57th St. Enjoy top-notch cuisine & ambience near at these restaurants near Carnegie Hall in Midtown Manhattan.
Where to Eat When Visiting Manhattan’s Museum Mile
Explore a diverse range of dining experiences near Manhattan's Museum Mile, from international cuisines like Austrian and Greek to classic Italian and French options.
Best Late Night Desserts in NYC
From iconic cannolis at Caffe Palermo in Little Italy to nostalgic desserts at Empire Diner, there are great places all around NYC when that late-night sweet tooth starts to tingle. Read on for great shakes, cakes, cookies, and more in the wee hours.
Utsav Introduces New Bengali Menu
Utsav, a woman-owned restaurant in the Theater District, has been serving a dynamic combination of Chinese and Indian cuisine now for more than 23 years. They've recently introduced a Bengali menu.
Parish Smith of EPMD: Taurus Birthday Bash at SOB's on 5/19/24
Parish Smith of EPMD Taurus Birthday Bash!! Performances by PMD, Smif n Wessun, Cold Crush Brothe
TOSOS@50 Pride Party at Red Eye NY on 5/20/24
Continuing its 50th Anniversary celebration, New York City’s oldest and longest producing LGBTQIA+ t
America’s Next Top Glow Up Runway Project at Caveat on 5/23/24
“America’s Next Top Glow Up Runway Project” is a comedy competition show hosted by Marina di Marzo —
Scandalton Live! at Caveat on 5/24/24
An improvised Jane Austen RPG show: You bring the tea, we spill it. Ever wanted courtside seats t