Forlini's Dining Review
Although it’s true that less-than-outstanding restaurants can become a habit despite their rather ordinary fare, Forlini’s doesn’t fall into that category. It’s anything but a restaurant serving gobs of mediocre food. Rather, it is a slice of Old New York that’s still a vibrant, bustling hangout (especially at lunch) for judges, political leaders and its long-time devoted clientele. Ed Koch had eaten lunch at Forlini’s the night I ate there. Each of the booths is dedicated to a judge (from the nearby courthouse) that’s a regular there. Manhattan District Attorney Robert Morgenthau also has a plaque-designated booth.
Forlini’s holds opera and wine maker dinners. It offers a Saturday and Sunday three-course $15.95 early bird special, a four-course gourmet dinner and, during the ten days before Christmas, customers receive a free bottle of wine and a Forlini’s calendar.
None of this was envisioned when Forlini’s opened in 1943. Derek Forlini, who now runs the restaurant with his two first cousins, Joe and Little Joe, recently recalled how “back then” customers had to put quarters into the rented air conditioners to keep cool.
Today, Forlini’s is a seven day a week, white table cloth restaurant with wood
paneled walls, leather bound wine lists and ornate art. One painting shows Mr. Forlini’s father and his two partners who moved the restaurant in 1956 after his grandfather founded it.
Unlike so many other Little Italy old time hangouts Forlini’s stresses quality, not quantity. Portions are healthy and manageable, not gargantuan, and ingredients are first rate. Additionally a sizeable olive oil dressed salad, vegetable or pasta is included in the price of entrees. The menu reads like the mother lode of Italian cooking. It’s dotted with Parmigianas, Marsalas, Piccatas, Cacciatores and Fra Diavolos. Yet, these conventional dishes often receive unconventional, interesting spins.
The tortellini stuffed with spinach and ricotta cheese comes with a lip-smacking pink sauce that I haven’t encountered elsewhere and the basil in the pesto sauce on the feathery gnocchi is enriched with just a touch of cream cheese.
Other dishes worth attention are the tiniest, tenderest, little baked clams Arreganata, the crisp rounds of fried zucchini and the lighter-than-air Panserotti Piacentina or delicate rolled crepes in a luxuriant creamy Bolognese sauce. Oh, yes, the Involtini di Gamberi or rolled shrimp, stuffed with Prosciutto, cheese and mushrooms might sound like it’s a little over the top, but it’s a harmonious blend that’s worth trying.
Also worth trying are sweets like the decadent chocolate mousse cake and the full bodied homemade cheesecake.
Finally, for those who have any doubts about Forlini’s Italian authenticity, know this: the bartender’s brother is on "The Sopranos."
93 Baxter St. @ Canal St., 212-349-6779.
New York City Activities
More Articles
Tony Awards After-Party Restaurants: Eat Like a Broadway Star at Rockefeller Center
From NARO to Jupiter, explore the Rockefeller Center restaurants hosting the exclusive Tony Awards after-party—and how to experience their menus today.
Authentic New York-Style Italian: NoLiTa's Rubirosa
Rubirosa in NoLita, Manhattan serves authentic Italian favorites, from thin-crust pizza to legendary Monday lasagna. Cozy atmosphere, locals’ favorite.
Playful Takes on Chinese Originals at RedFarm in the West Village
Discover RedFarm in the West Village, serving playful modern Chinese dishes, handmade dumplings, creative cocktails, and bold flavors.
A Tasting Menu to Remember at STK Steakhouse in the Meatpacking
Experience STK Steakhouse in the Meatpacking District. From tuna tartare to truffle tagliatelle, explore our review of their signature tasting menu and cocktails.
Family-Friendly NYC July 4th Fireworks Cruise on Lucille Yacht at Lucille on 7/4/26
FOR TICKETS OR MORE INFORMATION, VISIT US AT JULY4TH.COM Join us for an evening of fireworks, foo
Drafting Greatness: The Science and Style of Beer at Greats Of Craft, Waterfront on 6/30/26
Drafting Greatness: The Science and Style of Beer Six pours, centuries of history, and the scienc
WOMANIZER Music Video Release Party + Show w/ IMMATERIAL!, Colette March, Artina Darkly + more at The Broadway on 6/30/26
Join us for a night of burlesque, drag, music, dancing, and more as IMMATERIAL! premieres their musi
Jack and the Beanstalk: A Music Adventure at Culture Lab @ LIC on 6/28/26
"Jack and the Beanstalk: A Music Adventure" is a playful, interactive concert retelling of the class



